News Release: MN Bishops Urge Obama Administration to Protect Conscience Rights in Healthcare

New Rule could force religious organizations to choose between conscience and communities they serve

ST. PAUL, MINN. (September 27, 2011) –The Catholic bishops of Minnesota urged HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius in a recent letter to rescind the recent “preventative services mandate” rule imposed by the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA). The Rule would force private insurance plans to cover contraception and sterilization, and abortion-inducing drugs, like the recently FDA-approved drug “Ella.” They requested HHS instead broaden the protection of conscience in the implementation of the PPACA.

Although the bishops noted their support for providing access to services that truly prevent disease or disability for women, such as pap smears and mammograms, they are concerned that the Rule will treat fertility and pregnancy as abnormal states that are in need of prevention and force unprecedented restrictions on employers to act in violation of their informed conscience.

“Even if there are disagreements about abortion and birth control as public policy, the long-standing legislative tradition in the US has protected the freedom of conscience and religious beliefs,” said Jason Adkins, Executive Director of the Minnesota Catholic Conference (MCC), which represents the bishops of Minnesota on matters of public policy. “Requiring Catholic individuals and institutions to pay for and provide abortion drugs and contraceptives contrary to Catholic teaching in the name is ‘reproductive autonomy’ is an unprecedented attack on the cherished liberties of religious and associational freedom.”

The bishops noted that the new Rule is a reversal of the long tradition in the United States of conscience protections for faith-based providers. Additionally, they are disheartened by the “potential impact of the Rule on the vulnerable populations who have been served well and generously by Catholic providers for many decades in our country.”

“Not only Catholics, but millions of people of different faiths and outside the religious community are served through Catholic-affiliated social service programs and schools throughout the United States. The Rule will effectively insulate churches and religious organizations from the communities they serve,” Adkins said. “It will seriously affect the educational and social service network of the Catholic Church by preventing us from helping all of our brothers and sisters of other faiths and beliefs, while staying true to ours.”

The bishops also sent letters to the Minnesota congressional delegation asking them to sponsor the bipartisan Respect for Rights of Conscience Act (HR 1179), which would insure the PPACA would not be used to trample on religious and association freedom by forcing private health plans to provide services that are morally unacceptable. Additionally, they asked Catholics in Minnesota to voice their concern about the Rule by sending a letter about the mandate to HHS and the Minnesota congressional delegation no later than Friday, September 30, 2011.


* USCCB Preventive Services Backgrounder:
* NCHLA Online Action Alert template:

Share this page to spread the word.
Share Tweet